The admissions have closed it seems
To whomsoever it may concern
What percentile do i need for DFS/DBE in CAT 2020 10/12/btech - 88/78/71 2yrs Work ex in IT Category SC
Seats khali hain !
Just a honest try, you should also drop a mail, it is my kind request.
RTI filed !
This was the response I got, now I'm WL 2 in DSE, I hope they don't pull such a stunt.
Bhai UGC ko kaise complain kare ? Any help !
(Please help me, if this is written correctly or not, is there something I should add or subtract from this. I am mailing this to admission coordinator and dean, would write another mail to VC if this doesn't help.) Respected Sir/Mam, I don't know if writing this would serve any purpose, still I would like to try any possible way left, so that MBA(BE) program resume its WL movement till the last vacant seats are occupied. I don't know what is my WL number, so I am unsure if I would get selected even if the WL movement resumes, but still I don't want to feel myself, not trying hard despite having odd chances to get an admit. It is just because of the department's whim to close admission prematurely and inadequate WL moving procedure, I and many like me would get a year lost, had there been a WL movement in right manner, there were likely chances that I and many like me would have got an admit, but now the seats would remain empty. There are two issues that I want to highlight and therefore request the department to resume WL movement for MBA (BE) program for the vacant seats. First is the manner in which WL movement takes place. Even IIM's gives buffer call but why not DBE. This is the reason why all the seats get filled in IIM's and those who have chances of getting admit gets an admit, but DBE inefficient WL movement hampers this, and takes away chances from those who deserve. It brings aspirants to severe disadvantage. Second is that why only MBA(BE) closed it's admission prematurely, with vacant seats left. There has been WL movement in other colleges (FMS and DSE MBA) under the same University even in the month of September and I am pretty sure, that there would be further admission list released by them, if there are vacant seats left. MBA (BE) must do the same, by resuming WL movement. I therefore, once again request department to resume the WL moving and release further admission lists. If this isn't possible, then department must release the exact number of seats that remained vacant across all the categories this year. I hope department would consider my request, and would re-evaluate their decision about closing of WL movement. Though I am ready for disappointment, but still I hold hope, that department would understand, because there is severe loss to both department and to the aspirants in case the seats remain vacant. Regards
Mail 1
Reply
Mail 2
Ab VC du, UGC, MHRD aur PMO ko email jayega. Please suggest what to write. I am also waiting for the RTI, I filled, pata toh chale how much seats are left in total vacant this session. Mazzak bana rakha hai system ne, bhale hai yahan aspirant suicide point pe khada ho.
(bhai logon padh do, ki sab theek hai ki nahi, kuch add subtract karna ho toh batana )
Respected Sir,
I am writing this email, as a last hope that now; only you could help me and many others who are in a similar boat in regards to this year admission process. Sir, I am a general category MBA aspirant who have applied to this year MBA (BE) program under DEPT OF BUSINESS ECONOMICS SOUTH CAMPUS DU.
Sir, the department closed this year admission process for DBE MBA (BE) program even though many seats in the GEN category remain unfulfilled/vacant. The admission process that was followed by DBE for the admission had some inherent flaws.
First, due to COVID-19, Group Discussion & Personal Interview didn’t took place. It lead to change in criteria, that lead to severe disadvantage to many aspirants like me. As all the aspirants had to apply for DBE before the declaration of CAT 2019 results, there was an urgent need for a mechanism to get expression of interest from the pool of applicants as many applicants might have opted for different colleges according to their percentile. But nothing like this happened.
Also, the delay in the admission process called for an Expression of Interest. Unfortunately no such step was taken and admissions were offered to the whole pool of applicants based on merit. Due to this, admission was offered repeatedly in one after the other waiting lists to students who had either taken admission in other colleges or had other reasons to not join this course. This has resulted in unfulfilled seats even after 18 waitlists long process which lasted for almost 4 months, but completely useless. One must consider this fact, that at least past 7-8 WL, there has been double digit movement in every admission list in General category alone. Even after multiple requests to department for resuming the admission process, no one seems to help.
Many students like me who are further down in the waitlist were very keen to join this course. Unfortunately even after scoring much more than last year's cut-off, we are being denied admission, even though many seats are available, only due to the faulty admission process. It is an act of absolute injustice.
Sir, I converted DSE MBA (IB/HRD) and IIM Sirmaur program in the month of July. But I was adamant about joining DBE and was pretty sure, that had the admission process continued, I would have definitely got admit. But department’s whim to abruptly close admission process lead to extreme injustice to many aspirants like me, who are keen on joining this program.
Sir, please help us, I beg to you. This year has been extremely bad for humanity in general. Almost a year has been passed, since I entered this admission process. In the beginning of this year, when the CAT result was declared, I got 96.41 percentile which is much higher than last year cut-off for DBE, and was really hopeful that I would get admit in the place I hoped for since the beginning of the admission process. But then covid-19 struck, and all the dynamics got changed. I couldn’t join IIM-Sirmaur as I wasn’t able to pay the fees, nor couldn’t apply for loan within such a short span, belonging to a lower middle class family. Similar was the reason with IIM-Trichy HRM program. I converted DSE but I want to join the field of finance, for which DBE is a perfect place. And with my CAT score and good percentage in Class 10/12th (95/84), I was hopeful that I would be able to join this program. But all I now have is breakdown, misery, pain and frustration, being not being able to get admit, despite having being on right path, just because of department’s fault of closing admission process with so many vacant seats left. All the hard work and struggle, went in complete vain, because of the system inadequacy.
I once again request you to please completely fill the seats in MBA (BE) course by whatever necessary steps needed. Please organize spot round for the admission process. I beg to you.
Please consider this request from an honest hardworking aspirant, who would lose because of the systems ill-working, incompetency and faults.
Sir, there are many lives looking to you with a hope for justice and help.
Regards.
(mailing to director south campus du)
Bhai log ab kya kiya jaye ! Should I make another reply that what ever maybe the case you must atleast resume the admission.
Bhai logon agar tumhara composite score mujhse aacha ho toh tum bhi [email protected] Ko email kardo, only he could help, mail karne ke sirf 4 ghante mai pura biodata nikal kar bhar aagaya. Please I request you. I can't individually stand in this battle. Please request them to restart the admission.
( I am out of this resuming admission process fight, I guess I have tried my best, this is my last reply to the department. Only the god knows what would happen now (though I am an atheist). I am happy that I fought, despite all the odds. I wish you all the very best for life.)
Respected Sir,
Thank you very much for finally providing me, my final score and approximate rank, after so many emails.
Sir, as you have mentioned that the chances that I get final admission call from the department are extremely low. I completely respect your point, considering my waitlist number. But I want to highlight a few things.
Sir, I don’t know what is the exact number of seats vacant left for general category in MBA (BE) program, but I am expecting it to be between 15-20 considering the last waitlist movement released. It is worth highlighting that even after 4 long months and 18 waitlists, the department couldn’t fill 41 seats of general category; almost half of them remain empty as of today. It is almost mid September, so most of the people in the waitlist have either joined some other college or started looking/doing something else. I am myself started preparing for CAT 2020. So the chances, even if odds are that I and even a few people below me could make final convert, if department resumes admission. I would surely join the program if I get an admission call. All the department need to do is conduct a spot round. I don’t know what is stopping the department to fill the vacant seats.
Sir, I have been a failure all my life, just because of a very simple reason, I didn’t try, I feared, not fighting till the very end just because the chances of success looked very bleak. Had I honestly tried hard, I would have learned a lot, would have been successful and may not become the failure I am now. Sir, in this admission process, I tried to get over this failure of my character. Getting final admit or not, only the god knows, but at least I am now satisfied that I tried my very best alone, despite having odd chances and powerless against a system, to get the thing what I aimed for.
I would surely be very disappointed if I don’t get the final admission call, after all these attempts for resuming admission. But the more heartbreaking thing for me would be not get selected just because the department didn’t resume admission process, despite having vacant seats left. My luck has been extremely cruel on me all my life, so the probability of me getting admit are almost negligible even if the department resumes admissions, but I would be really happy if aspirants above me in the waitlist would who rightly deserve to admit would get admit, after all this struggle to resume the admission process, at least my honest tries would be helpful to someone else.
Sir, sometimes against all odds, against all logic, we hope that a thing could happen. Though I am pessimist, I still have a bleak hope, that I could get admit, if the department resumes admission.
Sir, I won’t be further approaching any higher authorities or would be making any other e-mail, with the purpose of requesting resuming the admission process. I guess I have tried my very best, to request the system to do the only right thing in most polite way possible.
It is now purely within the department conscience to decide what is right and wrong.
Sir, I thank you very much for providing me your extremely valuable time. I wish you all the very best for life and a prosperous future.
I am ending this e-mail with a hope that the human on the other side, would step in the shoes of the aspirants while making any further decision regarding the admission process.
Regards
A Common Man
Here is what I got as reply !
Iss Saal Saare Poll Galat Hue Hain, Ye Last One Hain Dekhte Hain Kya Hota Hain :
Would I be able to convert DBE, Current WL approx 400 :
- No
- Yes
0 voters