GMAT Data Sufficiency Discussions

Hi friends , i wasnt able to attach the jpg's . i have commpressed the two of my questions and uploaded in Ds.zip

pls help m with the answers and the reasoning

i will post the OA later


for interest question both statement sufficient to solve question

st1 from D(t) u can find value of r and from r value u will find D(t) after 3 year

st2

from r directy u can solve


each one sufficiet
for interest question both statement sufficient to solve question

st1 from D(t) u can find value of r and from r value u will find D(t) after 3 year

st2

from r directy u can solve


each one sufficiet


hi jigar....could you pls explain why st 1 is sufficient by itself...
if we know D(t) = 11000, how can we find r when t is also unknown...11000 may not be necessarily d amount after 1 year...it could be at any year t ...

11000 = (1+r/100)^t ..1 equation and 2 unknowns..not sufficient...
hi jigar....could you pls explain why st 1 is sufficient by itself...
if we know D(t) = 11000, how can we find r when t is also unknown...11000 may not be necessarily d amount after 1 year...it could be at any year t ...

11000 = (1+r/100)^t ..1 equation and 2 unknowns..not sufficient...


ya friend u totally correct

i am in half a sleep

1. B
2. C

Q35S30:

Ans C

we are interested in median no of employees assigned per project..
all we need to know is the value corresponding to 50th percentile

St 1: 4 is 75th percentile..( since 25 percent of projects have 4 or more employees )...not sufficient

St 2 : 2 is 35th percentile (SInce 35 percent of projects have 2 or fewer employees ) ...not sufficient..

Both statements combined ....3 is the 50th percentile ...SUfficient...Ans C


Can you explain the percentile funda and your approach?
vikas130678 Says
Can you explain the percentile funda and your approach?


median is the middle value...half of the values are equal to or above median and other half are equal to or below median...

Percentile is the % of values equal to or below a given value...hence median is the 50th percentile ...

in the above sum, No of employees per project is always an integer value..

Hence, If suppose there are 100 projects...and if these projects are arranged sequentially acc to no of employees in every project, we want to know the no of employees in the 50th project...

hence , first 35 proj have 2 or lesser employees and last 25 have 4 or more...hence all proj from 35th to 75th have 3 employees ..(no ambiguity in no of employees for 50th proj...sufficient)

This translates to : 2 is the 35th percentile and 4 is the 75th percentile...there is only one integer between 2 and 4 which necessarily has to be the 50th percentile ..

hope this helps...

Someone pls explain this.

Is x an even integer?
(1) x is the square of an integer.
(2) x is the cube of an integer.

Someone pls explain this.

Is x an even integer?
(1) x is the square of an integer.

(2) x is the cube of an integer.


Ans E...

St 1 : Perfect squares can be even or odd...not sufficient...
St 2 : Perfect cubes can be even or odd as well ...not sufficient...

ST 1 & st 2 : Sixth power of any integer wud be a perfect square as well as perfect cube...and sixth power of an integer cud be even or odd depending on whether integer is even or odd...not sufficient !!

Hey guys , thanks for the answers as well as the explanations !!!
the OA's are
for q10s30 its D(the explanition by bhavin is what i also assumed , but dunno y its mentioned D.Nonetheless i wud also go with B until someone provides some divine intervention on this one)
for q35s30 its C(got the explantion for this one,Thanks )

Someone pls explain this.

Is x an even integer?
(1) x is the square of an integer.
(2) x is the cube of an integer.


Ans: E

1) - Insufficient as the square of an integer can be even or odd
2) - Insufficient as the cube of an integer can be even or odd

Comb. both of them ---> Sub. some value for which square of an integer = cube of an integer

4^3 = 8^2 ---> X is even
1^3 = 1^2 ----> X is odd

Insufficient
Someone pls explain this.

Is x an even integer?
(1) x is the square of an integer.
(2) x is the cube of an integer.


1)x is the square of an integer=>x can end with 1,4,9,6,5,0 so,can be odd or even.

2)x is cube of an integer=>x can end with 1,8,7,4,5,6,3,2,9,0 so can again be odd or even

considering both the statements,x can be either odd or even.

option (E)
cannot be answered by the data.

What is the capacity of Pitcher ?

1) The total capacity of three 8-ounce cups is double the capacity of pitcher P
2) Pitcher P fills two 8 ounce cups

My answer is D
OA is A

for 2) Cant I make an assumption that the capacity of pitcher is equal to 16 ounce?

What is the capacity of Pitcher ?

1) The total capacity of three 8-ounce cups is double the capacity of pitcher P
2) Pitcher P fills two 8 ounce cups

My answer is D
OA is A

for 2) Cant I make an assumption that the capacity of pitcher is equal to 16 ounce?

I also initially thought that answer would be D, but later -second option says it can fill two 8 ounce cup- it doesnt mean that the pitcher is empty after filling two cups,may be it can fill 2.5 cups.

In the rectangular coordinate system, are the points (a, b) and (c, d) equidistant from the origin?
(1) a/b = c/d

(2)

Whats your answer?" />

In the rectangular coordinate system, are the points (a, b) and (c, d) equidistant from the origin?
(1) a/b = c/d

(2)

Whats your answer?


Answer should be C." />
In the rectangular coordinate system, are the points (a, b) and (c, d) equidistant from the origin?
(1) a/b = c/d

(2)

Whats your answer?


1. If the co - ordinates are (1,1) and (-1,-1). The co-ordinates are equidistant
Consider (1,2) and (2,4). These co-ordinates also satisfies the equation but they are not equidistant from origin.

A not sufficient

2. From this option, we can say that

a) a = (plus or minus) +- C, b = (plus or minus)+- d
b) a = (plus or minus) +- d, b = (plus or minus) +-c

In both cases the co-ordinates are equidistant from origin.

B is sufficient and thats my answer" />

How can you say from 2 that
a) a = (plus or minus) +- C, b = (plus or minus)+- d
b) a = (plus or minus) +- d, b = (plus or minus) +-c

2 says that the sum of (+-a) + (+-b) = (+-c) + (+-d)

BTW, the OA is C.

Vikas.mogle,

How did you arrive at your answer? Can you explain please.

How can you say from 2 that
a) a = (plus or minus) +- C, b = (plus or minus)+- d
b) a = (plus or minus) +- d, b = (plus or minus) +-c

2 says that the sum of (+-a) + (+-b) = (+-c) + (+-d)

BTW, the OA is C.

Vikas.mogle,

How did you arrive at your answer? Can you explain please.


from 1: a/b=c/d=k (constant)

From 2: a+b=c+d => substitute a=bk and c=dk in this

you get b=d and a=c

equidistant points (a,b) and (c, d) must satisfy a^2+b^2=c^2+d^2 condition.

You wrote that From 2: a+b=c+d => substitute a=bk and c=dk in this

Can we assume that square root (square of a ) = a? Or should it be (+-a)

For eg. square root ( 3 square) = square root (9) = +-3?

How can you say from 2 that
a) a = (plus or minus) +- C, b = (plus or minus)+- d
b) a = (plus or minus) +- d, b = (plus or minus) +-c

2 says that the sum of (+-a) + (+-b) = (+-c) + (+-d)

BTW, the OA is C.

Vikas.mogle,

How did you arrive at your answer? Can you explain please.


I made an assumption that the points are equidistant and looked at the second option. This question got me.

Thanks for pointing out.