GMAT Data Sufficiency Discussions

x is a positive integer, is the remainder 0 when 3^x + 1 is divided by 10?

1> x = 4n + 2
2> x>4


Ans A

Powers of 3 follow a cyclicity of 4 and we need to find a definite remainder for which we need a definite units place ..

St 1 : since power of 3 has been expressed in terms of multiples of 4, units digit would be same as 3^2 ...Definite YES ...suff

St 2 : variable units place poss ...not suff

P.S : I have a wierd feeling that Ans is E ...coz sum only states that x is an integer, which means i cannot assume n to be an integer, then ans changes ..
( i mean for x to be an integer, n could be integer or multiple of 0.5, in which case ans changes )
If x and y are nonzero integers, is x^y > y^x?
(1) x = y2
(2) y > 2


Ans C

St 1 : I guess it says x=y^2

Hence, it translates to y^2y > y^(y^2) ?...Not suff since 2y may or may not be greater than y^2 depending on the value of y .

St 2 : Nothing about x...Not suff

Combined : y is +ve and x is +ve, hence always 2y
Ans A

Powers of 3 follow a cyclicity of 4 and we need to find a definite remainder for which we need a definite units place ..

St 1 : since power of 3 has been expressed in terms of multiples of 4, units digit would be same as 3^2 ...Definite YES ...suff

St 2 : variable units place poss ...not suff

P.S : I have a wierd feeling that Ans is E ...coz sum only states that x is an integer, which means i cannot assume n to be an integer, then ans changes ..
( i mean for x to be an integer, n could be integer or multiple of 0.5, in which case ans changes )


I totally agree with you bhavin. Because

n=0 then x=2 => reminder is 0.
n=1/4 then x=3 => reminder is 8
n=1/2 then x=4 =. reminder is 2.

here we need not even consider -ve numbers to conclude that this option is insuff.

2) is also insuff and combining both we get no where near the answer.

I got this ques from another forum but there was no info on "n".

Anyways good discussion.
Ans C

St 1 : I guess it says x=y^2

Hence, it translates to y^2y > y^(y^2) ?...Not suff since 2y may or may not be greater than y^2 depending on the value of y .

St 2 : Nothing about x...Not suff

Combined : y is +ve and x is +ve, hence always 2y


Yes the answer is C.
Good conceptual question !!

Ans D

Perfect square always has an odd no of factors whose sum is also always odd ..

If required can post the proof for the same as well ..



Yes the answer is D.

Here is my expln:
Consider 1)

here N has an even number of factors. Lets take an example 4:
Factors of 4 are 1,2,4.
take 9. Factors of 9 are 1,3,9. Take 16, again factors are 1,2,4,8,16.

So N is not a perfect square. Hence 1) alone is suff.

Consider 2) Sum of factors is even. Consider the above examples and add the factors.All the sums are odd.

Hence 2) alone is sufficient.

Hence D.

:cheerio::cheerio::cheerio::cheerio:

Of the 60 animals in a farmhouse 2/3rd are either Pigs or Cows. How many of the animals are cows ?

1) The farmhouse has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs

2) The farm has more than 12 pigs

x is a positive integer, is the remainder 0 when 3^x + 1 is divided by 10?

1> x = 4n + 2
2> x>4


answer is A.

3^x=3^(4n+2)=9*81^n
if we divide the number by 10 , the remainder would be-9*1=9
so when 3^x+1 is divided by 10,rem will be-9+1=10/10= zero

for second statement, simply put values 5,6,7-remainder will be-4,0,8 respectvely
Good conceptual question !!

Ans D

Perfect square always has an odd no of factors whose sum is also always odd ..

If required can post the proof for the same as well ..


i think answer is E.
take the example of 3,
two distinct factors-1,3-even
sum of factors-1+3=4 even
but 3 is not a perfect square
x is a positive integer, is the remainder 0 when 3^x + 1 is divided by 10?

1> x = 4n + 2
2> x>4



Statement 1 alone is suff and statement 2 doesn't give a clue.
Of the 60 animals in a farmhouse 2/3rd are either Pigs or Cows. How many of the animals are cows ?

1) The farmhouse has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs

2) The farm has more than 12 pigs


it has to be A.
I believe cow and pig are the only two animals totalling 60.
so if cow are more than double of pigs,2/3 will be cow only.
Is the positive integer N a perfect square?

(1) The number of distinct factors of N is even.
(2) The sum of all distinct factors of N is even.


Each statement alone is suff to ans the q
it has to be A.
I believe cow and pig are the only two animals totalling 60.
so if cow are more than double of pigs,2/3 will be cow only.

Of the 60 animals in a farmhouse 2/3rd are either Pigs or Cows. How many of the animals are cows ?

1) The farmhouse has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs

2) The farm has more than 12 pigs


Both the statements are not sufficient to ans the q.

From the main statement 40 can be the no.of cows or pigs.But both the statements doesn't give any clue beyond this
If x and y are nonzero integers, is x^y > y^x?
(1) x = y2
(2) y > 2


combining both the statements will help to ans the q
Is the positive integer N a perfect square?

(1) The number of distinct factors of N is even.
(2) The sum of all distinct factors of N is even.

i think answer is E.
take the example of 3,
two distinct factors-1,3-even
sum of factors-1+3=4 even
but 3 is not a perfect square


Hey Gutsy ..

For all non perfect square integers (prime or composite) there are evn number of factors and perfect squares always have odd no of factors ..

So, if statement reads even no of distinct factors, it can never be a perfect square ...Hence sufficient ...And no surprise that 3 has even no of factors, all non perfect squares have to have even no of factors ..

Lets try to prove this :

Let us prime factorize any integer N and express as N=a^m*b^n*c^p*.......

Where a,b,c... are prime factors and m,n,p...are integers ..
Then,
No of factors is given as = (m+1)(n+1)(p+1).....

So, if N is a perfect square, prime factorizing leads to even powers for every prime factor ..
i.e m,n,p are even when N is a perfect square

SO, (m+1) , (n+1), (p+1) are all odd and their product is odd as well ..

And when N is not a perfect square, atleast one of the powers is odd, hence atleast 1 term of the series (m+1)(n+1)(p+1) is even and product is even ...

So St 1 is sufficient

St 2 : Similarly, trying to think of mathematical proof as to why for perfect squares, sum of distinct factors is odd ..
Though, this is a property of perfect sqaures and we can easily cross verify by trying first few perfect squares ..

Ans D
Of the 60 animals in a farmhouse 2/3rd are either Pigs or Cows. How many of the animals are cows ?

1) The farmhouse has more than twice as many cows as it has pigs

2) The farm has more than 12 pigs

it has to be A.
I believe cow and pig are the only two animals totalling 60.
so if cow are more than double of pigs,2/3 will be cow only.

Both the statements are not sufficient to ans the q.

From the main statement 40 can be the no.of cows or pigs.But both the statements doesn't give any clue beyond this


Ans C ..

We, know C+P = 40

St 1: C>2P ...multiple possible solutions ..Not suff
However, it is imp to realise that cut off value for no of pigs is 13 , ony then can the no of cows be more than double of no of pigs and yet add up to 40 ....
In other words, no of pigs have to be 13 or lower ...

St 2 : Alone tells u nothing

Combined : Definite answer ...pigs = 13, cows =27
( coz if pigs = 14, cows is 26 and 26 is not more than double of 14, so it violates the condition)

Hence, Ans C
Ans C ..

We, know C+P = 40

St 1: C>2P ...multiple possible solutions ..Not suff
However, it is imp to realise that cut off value for no of pigs is 13 , ony then can the no of cows be more than double of no of pigs and yet add up to 40 ....
In other words, no of pigs have to be 13 or lower ...

St 2 : Alone tells u nothing

Combined : Definite answer ...pigs = 13, cows =27
( coz if pigs = 14, cows is 26 and 26 is not more than double of 14, so it violates the condition)

Hence, Ans C

how can u make c+p=40?
it says either...or....
how can u make c+p=40?
it says either...or....


why can't i total up to 40 ? it says 2/3 of total of 60 are of either type ...

So there are a total of 40 animals , which are either cows or pigs.
So if one is x , other is 40-x
why can't i total up to 40 ? it says 2/3 of total of 60 are of either type ...

So there are a total of 40 animals , which are either cows or pigs.
So if one is x , other is 40-x


There are totally 60 animals of which 2/3 are either pigs or cows.

So, C+P =60 of which C or P can be 40 and the other is 20.

Can somebody post the OA for the cow-pig problem. There is enough discussion already and lets not pig around anymore.

prya.k Says
Can somebody post the OA for the cow-pig problem. There is enough discussion already and lets not pig around anymore.



The OA for this problem is C.