RC:
In Edgar Allan Poe's story 'The Imp of the Perverse', the protagonist carries out the perfect murder, inherits the dead man's estate, and lives for years in healthy enjoyment of his ill-gotten gains. Whenever thoughts of the murder appear on the fringes of his consciousness, he murmurs to himself, 'I am safe.' All is well until the day he remodels his mantra to 'I am safe - yes - if I be not fool enough to make open confession.' With that thought, he comes undone. He tries to suppress the thought of confessing, but the harder he tries, the more insistent the thought becomes. He panics, he starts running, people start chasing him, he blacks out, and, when he returns to his senses, he is told that he has made a full confession.
I love this story, for its title above all else. Whenever I am on a cliff, a rooftop, or a high balcony, the imp of the perverse whispers in my ear, 'Jump'. It's not a command, it's just a word that pops into my consciousness. When I'm at a dinner party sitting next to someone I respect, the imp works hard to suggest the most inappropriate things I could possibly say. Who or what is the imp? Dan Wegner, a social psychologist, has dragged the imp into the lab and made it confess to being an aspect of automatic mental processing. In Wegner's studies, participants are asked to try hard not to think about something, such as a white bear, or food, or a stereotype. This is hard to do. More importantly, the moment one stops trying to suppress a thought, the thought comes flooding in and becomes even harder to banish. In other words, Wegner creates minor obsessions in his lab by instructing people not to obsess.
Wegner explains this effect as an 'ironic process' of mental control. When controlled mental processing tries to influence thought ('Don't think about a white bear!'), it sets up an explicit goal. And whenever one pursues a goal, a part of the mind automatically monitors progress, so that it can order corrections or know when success has been achieved. When that goal is an action in the world (such as arriving at the airport on time), this feedback system works well. But when the goal is mental, it backfires. Automatic processes continually check: 'Am I not thinking about a white bear?' As the act of monitoring for the absence of the thought introduces the thought, the person must try even harder to divert consciousness. Automatic and controlled mental processes end up working at cross purposes, firing each other up to ever greater exertions. But because controlled processes tire quickly, eventually the inexhaustible automatic processes run unopposed, conjuring up herds of white bears. Thus, the attempt to remove an unpleasant thought can guarantee it a place on your frequent-play list of mental ruminations.
Why does the passage begin with a summary of an Edgar Allan Poe story?
1) To provide context for the name of the phenomenon studied in the rest of the passage, i.e. the imp of the perverse
2) To vividly depict the negative effects of the phenomenon studied in the rest of the passage
3) To illustrate through a literary example how the phenomenon studied in the rest of the passage works
4) To show that Edgar Allan Poe was the first person to identify and illustrate the phenomenon studied in the rest of the passage
According to Dan Wegner, the phenomenon that the author calls 'imp of the perverse' is the result of:
i] The malfunction of mental control processes.
ii] Two mental processes working against each other.
iii] Automatic mental processes being stronger than controlled mental processes.
1) Only [i] 2) Only [iii] 3) Both [i] and [ii] 4) Both [ii] and [iii]
Which of the following hypothetical experiments would best enable Dan Wegner to study the 'imp of the perverse' phenomenon?
1)The participants are asked to talk among themselves, without ever using the word 'the'.
2) Two films are shown to the participants, who are then instructed to think about the first one.
3) Twenty pens are placed before each of the participants, who are asked not to count them.
4) The participants are asked to write down their three favourite colours, then told not to think about the third one.
If you were to interview the author, what would be the best question to ask him?
1) Are there any other depictions of the 'imp of the perverse' phenomenon in literature?
2) Is there any way to successfully control the 'imp of the perverse' phenomenon?
3) What other experiments has Dan Wegner conducted to study the 'imp of the perverse' phenomenon?
4) Are there any other results of automatic mental processing that are similar to the 'imp of the perverse' phenomenon?
-IMS