RC Discussion for CAT 2013

@nole said:
@miseera@saurav205 RC of the day 26/3/2013For 42 question " The strikingsimilarities in both, between New Orleans jazz and gospel singing leads one to conclude either that there is a strong religious element in both or in neither"it is written either there is a strong religious element in both or in neither.so shouldn't the answer be C here?For 46 the line "the blues contain not only the traditional blues feeling but also undercurrents of despondence" hints that both religious elements and undercurrent of despondence is there. can anyone explain how the answer is A for this one ?
For q.42
Kindly go ahead and read the next line..as in the line after the line you have quoted...you should be able to figure out....

@nole For q46...read the first few lines if the para....the author says that the change is obvious....then goes on to elaborate on the changes..finally gibes the example of bird...so option.a.seems appropriate to me....option b and c can be rules out...option b i think has the word 'completely'..
@miseera Sirjee...__/\__
Possible ho toh oa and rc for the day post kar do...
@saurav205 OAs RC 28/03/2013

47. b
The author makes the point in the opening paragraph
where he mentions how at that time 'fine art' was
distinguished from commercial art in being regarded
as non-commercial which was not correct since it
was sold in galleries and auction rooms. This makes
choice (b) correct.

48. c
This influence is dealt with in the second paragraph
where the author mentions “His lessons were eagerly
… and kitsch.” This makes choice (c) correct.

49. c
The author talks about this in the second and third
paragraphs: “Just as the socialist … America”. He
further mentions: ”Although Warhol was probably …
of life”. This makes choice (c) correct.

50. b These values are mentioned in the third paragraph
and the author mentions: “The amoral … middle
America”. This makes choice (b) correct.

51. d
****'s article is mentioned in the fourth paragraph where
the author says that: “ **** Hebdige … high culture”.
This makes choice (d) the correct one.

52. b
The author while talking about Charles Saatchi in
paragraph 6, begins by stating that: “In public …” and
ends by saying “… museum of advertising”. He has
picked Saatchi and not some other member of the
bourgeoisie to show that in spite of what their affinities
are (Saatchi being an advertising man), in public they
patronize high culture. This makes choice (b) a more
apt answer.

53. a
The author mentions this in the seventh paragraph,
after mentioning the Saatchi example: “They truly
enjoyed … to be adopted”. He then goes on to mention
instances of this and makes the point that the
assimilation happens and is a miracle. This makes
choice (a) the most apt interpretation.

54. c
The author mentions Guston in the second last
paragraph and mentions that: “The iconography …
Mouse”. At the end of the passage, he further adds:
“His aim … cartoon films”. Choices (a) and (b) both
are correct. Therefore choice (c) is the answer.

55. c
A stumblebum is an awkward stupid person or a
second-rate prize fighter.


Happy CATing
http://blog.talkingphilosophy.com/?p=6594 A Good Read
@miseera Bhai Dil khush kr dia subah subah... after a all time all correct in an RC
@miseera all correct except 51 and 52 1.In 51 i made a blunder by not conc. much on FALSE so have marked C as an ans.
2. but in 52...i didn't get where
AFFINITY is mentioned...can u please explain regarding dis??
RC of The Day 29/03/2013

*Some of ACT UP's most powerful actions were copied from the South African anti-apartheid movement.
During the 1990s, we carried the ashes of people who had died of AIDS, or the actual bodies of the dead,
to the feet of those who contributed to their deaths through inaction or inappropriate action.


*The tactics of the global justice movement influenced ACT UP, and as the 1990s progressed ACT UP in
turn began to devote itself more strongly to global issues surrounding AIDS. When treatments began to
emerge that helped rich HIV positive people live longer and healthier lives, activism became more important
than ever because the majority of people with AIDS in the developing world had almost no access to these
treatments.


*It is estimated that 25-40 percent of people aged between 15 and 45 years in some areas of Africa are
infected with HIV. Life expectancy in some African nations has been reduced by 25-33 percent, from 60
years of age or more to 40 years or less. An estimated 4 million people in Africa will die of AIDS this year,
and there are already millions of AIDS orphans.


*An estimated 90 percent of people with HIV live in developing countries and have no access to any proven
treatments for HIV. Patients with drug-resistant tuberculosis and other deadly diseases also need medications
they cannot possibly obtain due to their price. Patented drugs are often priced ten times higher than is
necessary to make a profit.


*Until a few years ago, the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) did not cover pharmaceutical
patents, and few cared if developing countries quietly made copies of needed patented drugs; large
pharmaceutical corporations had no viable market in those countries anyway. But under today's GATT,
which was set up at the World Trade Organization (WTO), drug companies have become extraordinarily
aggressive in enforcing patent rights around the world, no matter what the cost to public health and welfare.


*Global trade laws allow exceptions to patent protection in some cases. The WTO's Trade-related Aspects
of Intellectual Property (TRIPs) agreement includes provisions for “compulsory licensing” and “parallel
importing”. Governments can respond to a medical emergency by manufacturing generic equivalents of
patented drugs locally or by importing such drugs at the lowest available world price. The United States
commonly uses the compulsory licensing provision itself — for cable television, music, and computer
technology, for example — but has furiously opposed efforts by Thailand, South Africa, and other developing
countries to use the same provisions for lifesaving medications.


*The US government (including the US Trade Representative, the State Department, the executive branch
and the Congress) has in recent years supported the multinational pharmaceutical companies seeking to protect their patent rights, without balancing concern for human lives. US government policy is more
restrictive that the WTO agreement and the US government has used its clout to stop other countries from
providing critical drugs to their own citizens by threatening economic sanctions.


*Drug companies say they need to protect their profits in order to recoup the development (R & D) of new
drugs. But this is a major exaggeration. Many drugs — including the AIDS drugs AZT, ddl, dC, D4T, 3TC,
and ritonavir (Norvir), and cancer drugs like paclitaxel (Taxol) — were largely developed by the National
Institutes of Health (NIH) or by university researchers with funding from NIH grants. US taxpayers paid for
much of the research on these drugs, and then the government aided universities licensed them to drug
companies (sometimes in the final phase of clinical trials) for very small royalty payments, sometime as
little as 1.5 percent of sales. The R&D; costs for many drugs that have generated billions of dollars in sales
were mostly paid with tax dollars, with the drug companies' investment limited to the final stages of the
clinical trial process. Such costs have long since been recouped.


*In addition, drug companies invest surprising little in R&D.; For example, Abbott's 1998 annual report listed
R&D; costs as 9.8 percent of sales. The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America
(PhRMA), an industry trade association, spends an average of 30 percent of sales on marketing. In addition,
drug companies' return to investors is the highest of any industry, averaging 25 percent, but in some cases
topping 33 percent. Pharmaceutical companies are among the richest corporations on the planet.


*Generic versions of antiretroviral drugs such as AZT, ddI, and ritonavir are being produced and in some
cases are already being sold for less than 10 percent of the cost of the patented equivalent.


41. According to the author, what was the most likely reason for ACT UP to copy actions from the South
African anti-apartheid movement for the anti-AIDS movement?
a. The two movements were funded by the same set of institutions and it was advised that the
successful tactics of the former should be adopted.
b. Anti-AIDS movement was considered a global justice movement and the tactics of similar
movement such as anti-apartheid was considered useful.
c. The schism between the haves and the have-nots were similar and the target audience for the
two movements was same as well.
d. The leaders of the two movements were the same and the stage on which these were played was
also the same — South Africa.

42. The author uses the figures regarding life expectancy, mortality rates to corroborate what point?
a. Africa is threatened most by this scourge and developed countries need to provide financial aid
to these patients.
b. The treatments developed for HIV are expensive whereas majority of the victims live in poor
countries.
c. The majority of the affected population is the youth and this would lead to population problems in
Africa.
d. None of the above


43. According to the passage, which statement is false with reference to research and development of
drugs?
a. Most of the drugs that drug companies claim as being developed by them are in fact developed
by the funding of NIH.
b. The drug companies come into the picture when the universities and government license it out.
c. The drug companies pay royalty payments of 50 % to these institutions.
d. Drug companies' investment is limited to the final stages of the clinical trial processes.

44. According to the passage, which one of these statements is false?
a. R & D costs for drug companies are 9.8 Percent of the sales according to Abbott's 1998 research.
b. PhRMA is an industry trade association.
c. The return to investors for drug companies is at an average of 25 %.
d. PhRMA states that R & D costs are 20 % of the profits.

45. What is the tone of the author in the passage?
a. Argumentative b. Critical c. Descriptive d. Supportive

46. Which statement is the author most likely to agree with?
a. Countries like US use the WTO rules according to what suits their needs.
b. WTO as opposed to the earlier GATT regime is more aggressive.
c. WTO was set with the express need to provide stringent laws for international laws on drug
patents.
d. The WTO is covertly funded by the big drug companies.

47. The passage uses
a. 12 acronyms b. 15 acronyms c. 9 acronyms d. 14 acronyms

48. According to the author, what would be the logical extension of this passage?
a. GATT will allow parallel production of patented drugs for AIDS/HIV treatment.
b. A resolution forbidding patenting lifesaving medications will be passed at the UN.
c. All lifesavings drugs would henceforth be free.
d. The US Govt. will review its support to the multinational pharmaceutical companies and will use
its clout to provide critical drugs at extremely low prices.


Happy CATing

P.S- (*)

@miseera said:
RC of The Day 29/03/2013 *Some of ACT UP's most powerful actions were copied from

@miseera said:
41. According to the author, what was the most likely reason for ACT UP to copy actions from the SouthAfrican anti-apartheid movement for the anti-AIDS movement?a. The two movements were funded by the same set of institutions and it was advised that thesuccessful tactics of the former should be adopted.b. Anti-AIDS movement was considered a global justice movement and the tactics of similarmovement such as anti-apartheid was considered useful.c. The schism between the haves and the have-nots were similar and the target audience for thetwo movements was same as well.d. The leaders of the two movements were the same and the stage on which these were played wasalso the same — South Africa.42. The author uses the figures regarding life expectancy, mortality rates to corroborate what point?a. Africa is threatened most by this scourge and developed countries need to provide financial aidto these patients.b. The treatments developed for HIV are expensive whereas majority of the victims live in poorcountries.c. The majority of the affected population is the youth and this would lead to population problems inAfrica.d. None of the above43. According to the passage, which statement is false with reference to research and development ofdrugs?a. Most of the drugs that drug companies claim as being developed by them are in fact developedby the funding of NIH.b. The drug companies come into the picture when the universities and government license it out.c. The drug companies pay royalty payments of 50 % to these institutions.d. Drug companies' investment is limited to the final stages of the clinical trial processes.44. According to the passage, which one of these statements is false?a. R & D costs for drug companies are 9.8 Percent of the sales according to Abbott's 1998 research.b. PhRMA is an industry trade association.c. The return to investors for drug companies is at an average of 25 %.d. PhRMA states that R & D costs are 20 % of the profits.45. What is the tone of the author in the passage?a. Argumentative b. Critical c. Descriptive d. Supportive46. Which statement is the author most likely to agree with?a. Countries like US use the WTO rules according to what suits their needs.b. WTO as opposed to the earlier GATT regime is more aggressive.c. WTO was set with the express need to provide stringent laws for international laws on drugpatents.d. The WTO is covertly funded by the big drug companies.47. The passage usesa. 12 acronyms b. 15 acronyms c. 9 acronyms d. 14 acronyms48. According to the author, what would be the logical extension of this passage?a. GATT will allow parallel production of patented drugs for AIDS/HIV treatment.b. A resolution forbidding patenting lifesaving medications will be passed at the UN.c. All lifesavings drugs would henceforth be free.d. The US Govt. will review its support to the multinational pharmaceutical companies and will useits clout to provide critical drugs at extremely low prices.Happy CATing P.S- (*)

I am not good in RC passages
@Buck.up said:
I am not good in at RC passages

You never good in Something,you always Good AT

@miseera

b
a
c
d
a
a
d
d

RC OF THE DAY 29/3/2013

41. c
42. d
43. c
44. d
45. a
46. a
47. d
48. b

RC OF THE DAY...
b,b,c,d,b,a,d,a

@saurav205 said:
@nole For q46...read the first few lines if the para....the author says that the change is obvious....then goes on to elaborate on the changes..finally gibes the example of bird...so option.a.seems appropriate to me....option b and c can be rules out...option b i think has the word 'completely'


option b has complete removal and a has only removal, which i think means option A speaks about religious feelings getting replaced(not fully) by undercurrents of despondenc,and hence option A is the answer ??
@nole said:
option b has complete removal and a has only removal, which i think means option A speaks about religious feelings getting replaced(not fully) by undercurrents of despondenc,and hence option A is the answer ??
Yes...thats what i thought when i marked a as the option...
SOURCE: ADAPTED FROM : Bryson, B., 2003. A Short History of Nearly Everything: 197-199
CARBON DATING

If you were interested in finding out about the age of things in the 1940s, the University of Chicago was the place to be. This was when Willard Libby, a researcher there, discovered radiocarbon dating. This lead to a process that would allow scientists to get more accurate readings of the age of bones and other organic remains than ever before, and would result in Libby being awarded the Nobel Prize in 1960.
Before Libby's discovery, the oldest reliable knowledge of historical time could only go back as far as the First Dynasty in Egypt, to around 3,000 BCE. No-one could confidently claim, for example, when the ice sheets from the last Ice Age had retreated, or at exactly what time in the past Cro-Magnon Man had decorated the caves of Lascaux in France, even though there were organic remains from these events.
Libby's discovery and the subsequent inventions were based on the realisation that all living matter contains an isotope, now called carbon-14, which begins to decay at a measurable rate as soon as an organism dies. Carbon-14 has a 'half-life' – in other words, the time it takes for half of a sample to disappear – of about 5,600 years. Therefore, by calculating how much of a specific sample of carbon had decayed, Libby could accurately determine the age of an object.
However, even this advanced form of dating had its limitations. After eight half-lives, only 0.39% of the original radioactive carbon would remain in the sample. At this point it would become too insignificant to make a reliable measurement. For this reason, radioactive carbon dating worked only for objects of about forty thousand years old. Other flaws in the technique began to appear later. To begin with, one of the basic components of Libby's formula, known as the 'decay constant', was inaccurate by about 3%. Unfortunately, by the time this error was discovered, thousands of measurements had been made throughout the world. Rather than correcting all these errors, scientists decided to keep the inaccurate constant. This is not a major problem for the theory. It simply means that researchers have to factor in the correction that 'raw' results from radiocarbon dating are too young by about 3%.
Another problem which carbon-dating faced was the ease with which it could be contaminated. Even a tiny scrap of vegetable matter, for example, could distort the reading. For younger samples of around twenty thousand years, this was not significant. However, it could seriously distort readings from older samples in which there were only a few remaining atoms.
There was also a wrong assumption in Libby's method. He had assumed that the amount of carbon-14 in the atmosphere, and the rate at which it has been absorbed by living things, has been consistent throughout history. In fact, it has not. We now know that variations in the Earth's deflection of cosmic rays causes fluctuations in the volume of atmospheric carbon-14.
Finally, readings based on carbon-dating of human remains can be thrown out by seemingly unrelated factors, such as the diet of whose bones are being tested. For example, a diet consisting entirely of fish can make bones appear older than they actually are.
Because of the accumulated shortcomings of carbon-14, scientists devised other methods of dating ancient materials. One of these was 'thermoluminescence' which measures electrons trapped in clays. Another was 'electron spin resonance' which bombards a sample with electromagnetic waves and then measures the vibrations of the electrons. However, none of these techniques was able to accurately date anything older than about two hundred thousand years. So at this stage of scientific discovery and invention, no-one was yet able to accurately determine the age of the planet. In fact, the difficulties of dating inorganic matter such as rocks seemed insurmountable, and scientists had almost given up. Indeed, had it not been for an extremely determined English professor named Arthur Holmes, this line of enquiry might have been abandoned completely.
CARBON DATING 1 - QUESTIONS
1. Which is true: Radiocarbon dating was discovered...
(a) ....by Willard Libby at the University of Chicago. (b) ...when Willard Libby was a student in Chicago.
(c) ....during the 1940s age of bones in Chicago. (d) ... to gain the Nobel Prize for Chicago University.
2. Which is cannot be inferred from the second paragraph (lines 5-9) ?
(a) The last Ice Age retreated before the first Egyptian dynasty in 3,000 BCE.
(b) French cave decorations were completed before the first Egyptian Dynasty.
(c) Cro-Magnon Man could not be accurately dated before Libby's discovery.
(d) The caves at Lascaux were decorated before the last Ice Age retreated.
Libby's discovery was based on the realisation that all living matter contains an isotope, now called carbon-14, which begins to decay at a measurable rate as soon as an organism dies. Carbon-14 has a 'half-life' – in other words, the time it takes for half of a sample to disappear – of about 5,600 years. Therefore, by calculating how much of a specific sample of carbon had decayed, Libby could accurately determine the age of an object.
3. PARAPHRASE THE ABOVE PARAGRAPH, BEGINNING: When an organism dies, .
[Write the answer in the space provided on the answer paper]
4. The error in Libby's formula was not corrected because....
(a) ...it contained only a small percentage of error. (b) ...too many samples had already been tested using it.
(c) ...the mistake was only recently discovered. (d) ...scientists decided not to tell anyone about it.
5. Which statement about the effects of sample contamination is true:
(a) It is unimportant and never leads to inaccuracy. (b) Older samples might be inaccurately dated.
(c) Dating of young samples will be very inaccurate. (d) All samples will be very inaccurately dated.
6. Which is true: The level of atmospheric carbon-14...
(a) ...steadily increases. (b) ...remains very constant. (c) ...generally declines (d) ...goes up and own
7. What does 'it' (line X) refer to?
(a) a wrong assumption (b) Libby's research method
(c) atmospheric C-14 absorption (d) the history of the Earth
8. What does 'thrown out' mean, as it is used in paragraph X, line x ?
(a) eliminated (b) expelled (c) emitted (d) distorted
9. What does 'this line of enquiry' in the above paragraph (line x) refers to the attempt to...
(a) ...age natural materials such as clay. (b) ...measure the vibrations in pieces of rock
(c) ...scientific discovery and invention. (c) ...calculate how old the planet Earth is
My take on CARBON DATING RC:@Ali_alrashed
1)(a) ....by Willard Libby at the University of Chicago
2)(d) The caves at Lascaux were decorated before the last Ice Age retreated.
4)(b) ...too many samples had already been tested using it.
5)(b) Older samples might be inaccurately dated.
6)(d) ...goes up and own
8)(d) distorted
9)(c) ...calculate how old the planet Earth is
@Ali_alrashed CARBON DATING RC:
1.a
2.d
4.a
5.b
6.d
7.b
8.d
9.b

@Ali_alrashed CARBON DATING RC:
1.a
2.d
4.a
5.b
6.d
8.d
9.b

OA RC 29/03./2013

41. b
The first Para mentions this - “Some of the …
Movement”. Further in the second para – “The
tactics….” This indicates that choice (b) is correct
and the rest of the options are not corroborated by the
passage.

42. b
The author states these figures in the second para
and mentions – “When treatment…..these treatments”.
The author, after stating the figures mentions “ An
estimated…..to their price”. This makes choice (b) the
correct one.

43. c
The third para delves into the claim of the drug
companies that the reason for the prohibitive costs is
the R & D investment. The author mentions “But this is
a …..of sales”. This corroborates statements (a) and
(b). Further, “The R & D costs…..trial processes”. This
means choice (d) is also correct. The author mentions
royalty but the correct figure stated is “as little as 1.5
%”. This makes choice (c) false and hence the correct
one.

44. d
The fourth para deals with this question. “For
example….of sales”. The author states that “The
Pharmaceutical……20 percent of sales”. This makes
choice d false since it mentions R & D costs as
20 percent of profits. This makes choice (d) correct.
45. b
The author is exploring the issue of the fact that a high
percentage of HIV patients are in the third world
countries whereas the new developments in the
treatment are expensive and the justification used by
the drug companies of high investments are also false.
This attitude is critical and this makes choice (b)
correct.

46. a
The author's stand vis-à-vis the WTO and GATT is
mentioned in the second para. He mentions the impact
of the regime change – “But under today's…..and
welfare”. “Global…..some cases”. He further mentions
the specific cases where the US has used clauses to
benefit it in some cases. This makes choice (a) correct.
Choice (b) is incorrect as the passage mentions the
drug companies being more aggressive under the
WTO. Choice (c) and (d) is not borne out by the content
of the passage.

47. d Fourteen acronyms are used in the passage.

48. d
(a) is unlikely because the US exerts clout over the
organizations. (b) and (c) are impossible situations
(d) is within the scope of the passage.


Happy CATing