Compare B-Schools (IIMs, FMS, XLRI, JBIMS, SPJAIN, MDI, IIFTs, IITs, etc)

Hello call getters, 

Congratulations to the one who have finally made it into IIM Sambalpur family. We are forming a WhatsApp group for those have converted and those who are on the waiting list. All interested students are requested to send a screenshot of your Converted Mail or Waitlist Mail and ping on either of these numbers to get into IIM Sambalpur WhatsApp group. 

1) 9475696019- Debanjali 

2) 8584088090- Debayan

DFS vs new iim? will give cat 18 while studying

A sad story of a BSchool pass out student (in worst case consider it as suicide note), an work of fiction 

I request you all to read this , before forum is forced to remove this one , request to the forum make it a free space for telling the truth.

This story is a fictitious one any resemblance with any organisation is Just a coincidence 

Today we will tell you a story say about a so called FICTITIOUS semi-famous, running almost a decade long, bschool in a state which is Almost in the middle of India (location is just an assumption ), we don’t want to mention a name, cause we were threatened by one of the most powerful persons from the institute that if we disclose the true information about it , they will use all their power to frame us as criminal and ruin our career .So your job is to put your grey matter into work and figure it out ,hope you don’t want us see ruined or shot dead. Before we begin friends just tell us , What is a crime between 1.telling a true story, asking for help when in distress, after being ruined by some of your own peers AND 2.publishing inflated false reports, Luring innocent people into a glittering trap and then put them through all psychological torture designed by selected some of them who are capable to doing so.

Trust me this story could be an appeal of change or help from people who are trapped badly probably we need this message reached to right authority who are completely ignorant of such Wrong-doings. No more airy talk let’s get straight into something that can be useful for you 

Placement condition of this fictitious institute

1.Almost 30% (more than 65 students) of batch got final placement package <=8.5 lakhs, fixed less than 7LPA.2.some of the students got no fixed component in their package, they left the job.

3. No student got a package more than 19 LPA in current year placement 2.some of the students more than 10 remained unplaced due to various reasons like IE and others

4. Almost 70% of the batch placed in start-ups, which does not have any guarantee of operations after 1-2 years 5.almost 20-30% of the past batch have become unemployed because of this last reason mentioned 

6. In summers almost half of this batch was placed through self-contact in internship, not by the institute, they had 0 stipend which was not calculated while publishing the report. Most of the rest awere placed in new start-ups again , very less number of brands.

6.1-no one got a stipend more than 50k/m in this batch 7. Report is not audited and more than 100% inflated figures

How do you verify this above information:-

We did not know it but If you have doubt about any report published by an institute, let me tell you what to do? Go to the placement report (final /summer) - check what the data like salary figures, company names are .Pick up the best figures and brand (example , say company name mentioned <JP morgan> , or a figure mentioned 3lakhs stipend) Do not ask anyone just prepare an RTI in the below format --

Item 1 -<company name> a. When the company did visited the campus for placement? b. how many students they recruited c. what package they offered ?

(Seek info from both the college and the company)

Item 2<student 3l> a. which company offered the stipend b. what is the job profile and location .which Company audited the report? etc.

Continue items for every companies or figures and send the RTI, if you get any satisfactory reply from both institute and company, then only believe .mostly data won’t be published by the college citing some strange reason. 

Psychopathic rules of the fictitious college:1. Here it seems sole purpose of one student committee is to how to prevent a student from getting a job or placement

2. They will debar you from placement if u enter the committee’s room mistakenly 

3. They will debar you if your formals are not of Particular colour (even if it is in proper colour, but a little bit shiny one, you will be debarred) 4.This committee members will treat you as slaves or dogs, u have to do whatever they say, else your carrier is finished No one will help you, trust me ,Even if someone ruined so much and takes some extreme decision of say ending life. Report will be published that you could not take the academic pressure, but no one tell that it was a subtle instrumental murder. 

4. Irrespective of their profile good or bad, surprisingly you will find all committee members and some lickers are placed in good companies. They created that joke when batch topper did not get a good placement. That literally happened many times in this college 

5. In this fictitious institute even you are deserving candidate your CV will be misplaced so that it did not get selected by the employers if u have any argument with them.

It happened that one student had some personal argument with one of the members, so the committee reported bad things to HR of company about that person and revoked the offer he got. Even the incident was reported to the highest authority no suitable action was NOT taken against this potential criminal activity by some students.

6.You have to be awake all through night so that whenever they call , u need go and meet them (I don’t know who they are , this is a fiction story.)

Repeatedly people wanted to get rid of a student committee and no one just listens 

Hostel and Food

In our fictitious story we have mentioned that you be treated as dog or slave , so here you have to stay in 4 sharing dark and damp rooms in the basement like prison cells , although people may deceive you that No , the situation is very good , they will post fake picture ,but trust me once you reach the college building , just check every possible corner first , you will get to know , but you won’t be allowed as they will put you inside a room until you pay the money in full, then they will allocate hostel room.

Food – insects are free along with food, It tastes like shits, every time students complain they tell this time new vendors are coming we will release new tender, and the tender goes to same food vendors. By the way it’s all fictitious right. Just making you remember, in case you forgot.

Academics –No comments, as no one is really concerned, but if you plan to do finance here, you are dead and Just by seeing few people, you feel like if they can teach u, then you also can beat Obama in USA.

Conclusion: remember you pay a lot of money for this MBA , in this fictitious college , plus you lose 2 years , what is your opportunity cost ,?,not less than 30 lakhs . Now what is your value addition –nothing . Unstable job , low salary , poor and traumatic experience all over two years .Are you sad you are not selected in this fiction-college ?, trust me you should not be , u may be lucky.

Suggestion that no one will give you: MBA worths waiting, until you get a really good to better college, may be from abroad .Having key skill does matter, not a degree which does not give your ability to work in the industry. You may find some similarity with some college, but you don’t have to trust us , it’s always your decision . Whatever you choose , we wish good luck always .


Please give honest opinion. Which college to choose - IIM Trichy, IIFT Kolkata or IIM Udaipur.

I have work ex of 27 months and am interested in marketing and finance.

The choices are very confusing. I'm in a dilemma. Please help guys with proper explanation.

  • IIM Sambalpur
  • IRMA
  • IIM Bodh Gaya

0 voters

 I have calls from IIFT Kolkata,IIM Tirchy. I am waitlisted for NITIE(ISEM) and SIBM Pune. I am confused among these two. Since the placement report of the Kolkatta campus. I am inclined towards IIFT but  don't want to be trapped . Please help.  

It is crystal clear that IIM A,B,C are top 3 institue in the country. IIM L,XLRI,FMS ranks from 4-6. 

Now among IIM K,IIM I, SPJAIN, IIFT D, MDI, NITIE what should be the order of ranking among these institute. No specialisation preference.

MY Take IIM K>IIM I>SPJAIN>IIFT D>NITIE>MDI

 

according to me ranking must be-

IIM A

IIM B

IIM C

FMS Delhi

IIM L

XLRI

IIM K

IIM I

SPJAIN

MDI

Now, there are five institute which are really good but somehow either they ar trade specific or have unique management courses-

ISB Hyderabad-YLP program for freshers and special program for people with work-ex>3years.

IIFT Delhi-International business

NITIE Mumbai- Operation and supply chain

TISS-HRM

JBIMS- MMS program and basically not an all india college. A dream college for maharastrians.

I guess these institute are the top 15 institute in India. Guys Do you agree??

which should i prefer iimu or iimt? U has audited placement,near to my home. T has smaller batch size, higher average placement, considered better than U. Not inclined towards any specialization. Please do comment reasons.

  • Udaipur
  • Trichy
  • Poll

0 voters

Am I the only one who thinks that people are just over-obsessed about rankings?...i have met tons of people who are entrepreneurs or c-level execs or top-level managers from not-so-famous undergrad and grad schools...i mean why can't we all just stop comparing whether mdi is better than iim k or fms is better than iim L and so on...is it simply because in our Indian society(no idea about foreign countries) we are never taught to celebrate 'averages'(although being in top 15 b-schools is not average but you get my point)..a lot of us are chasing brands just to add some good names on our CVs( and a lot of people have no clear idea why they want to pursue mba)....i might be wrong but after giving almost 15 interviews this season and talking to almost 50-60 people this was my observation

Do someone knows how is TISS Tulijapur - MA in Rural development in terms of future scope & placement?

 Hello call getters,  

Congratulations to the one who have finally made it into IIM Sambalpur family. We are forming a WhatsApp group for those have converted and those who are on the waiting list.  

All interested students are requested to send a screenshot of your Converted Mail or Waitlist Mail and ping on either of these numbers to get into IIM Sambalpur WhatsApp group.

1) 9475696019- Debanjali  

2) 8584088090- Debayan 

Which one is better amongst imi delhi bfs and tapmi bkfs?

How MDI is for Consulting/ Finance as compared to IIM K and IIM I?

Your call?

  • IIM Kashipur
  • IRMA

0 voters

Hello Guys,   Again congratulations to the one who have finally made it into IIM Sambalpur family. We have formed a WhatsApp group for those have converted and those who are on the waiting list.   All interested students are requested to send a screenshot of your Converted Mail or Waitlist Mail and ping on either of these numbers to get into IIM Sambalpur WhatsApp group. 1) 9475696019- Debanjali   2) 8584088090- Debayan 

Which is better among these? Please do post your comments below guys.

  • IIM Nagpur
  • IIM Indore HRM

0 voters

Which is better among IIM Bodhagay,IIM Sirmaur,IIM Sambalpur.I am an Electrical Engineer and have a work experience of 4 years in Power Distribution Opeartions.I had left my job last year.Please guide where to go,interested in finance.

Hello. I have converted both K and I. There are people telling me that K is much better than I. I'd like to know the reasons. As per the placement reports, I beats K. I has locational advantage and also boasts of a better campus.

Hello guys. I had registered for cat coaching with career launcher for attempting cat 2018. It includes offline classes, books, online login which has e lib, test gym, 30plus full mock tests, everyday gk update, vocab, 100s of sectional Tests, exam and detailed analysis, etc etc for cat/xat/snap/iift/nmat. But now i am discontinuing with mba as i've got an admit for masters in Germany. They don't have refund. So im willing to share my login details and all books with someone whose interested. I have paid 22K for the entire course. I have the paid Bill as well. Want to sell the complete things for 15K. Only interested learners reply. Genuine reason.