Check out @madhav_93's Tweet: https://twitter.com/madhav_93/status/832880538662817794?s=08 Kindly retweet if possible/applicable. Thank you.
This is from last year's thread
" I filed an RTI query to IIT Delhi on why I was not showrtlisted and I received the reply today. My details are as follows:CAT 2015 - 99.76 %ile10th/12th - 91.4/88.4B.Tech (IIT Madras) - 8.02/10IITD/RTI/2016/277/146My shortlisting Index (SI) score was 76.36. For General Category, the cutoff SI score was 78.21.Breakup of my weightage was:Weightage for CAT score: 59.86/60Weightage for Bachelor Degree - 4.5/15Weightage for 10+2 class marks - 6/10Weightage for 10 class marks - 4/5Weightage for work experience - 2/5Weightage for additional qualification - 0Total weight for shortlisting index - 76.36So here's the thing. I got 8.02/10 CGPA from IIT Madras and I get 4.5/15 in Bachelor score. Did clerical goof up cost me my call? I urge all other disaffected Puys who didn't get a call from IITD to shoot an RTI query. I think they have messed up somewhere."
It seems the same goofup was there last year also...
Does this mean that all the candidates not shortlisted with good CAT scores and decent profiles had CGPA in graduation? And there is a bug in IITD program for calculating composite scores? This is just a theory. Can be substantiated if all the guys with decent CAT score and profiles and not shortlisted confirm the same?
Dear All,
We Apologise for the delay. We are just facilitating the admission process, the shortlisting is done by the management.
Kindly post all your queries to [email protected], you will receive an official response for the same.
Regards,
AdCom, DMS IITD
Kya phoonk re hai ye iit delhi wale......... At least come clean about the cutoff @adcom
There is only GD and PI, no WAT right?
Dear All,
Good Evening. This is with regards to the shortlist for the Admissions Process 2017 of the Department of Management Studies, IIT Delhi. We understand that you have genuine concerns regarding the selection criteria and the admissions committee per se has taken it to the department as well. Since, the department is closed for the weekend, kindly give us some time to get back to you. Meanwhile, you can do the following:
1. Kindly send your queries and concerns to [email protected] with your CAT Score Card attached. CC it to [email protected] . You will get an official response to your query with the details.
2. Kindly be patient and maintain the decorum. As B-school aspirants you should understand that such challenges are a part of one’s professional journey. Please do not hurl abuses to the sanctity of the college that you look forward to.
We value your interest in our MBA programme and we also understand your sentiments.
Thank you for your time and patience.
With Warm Regards,
Swapna Joshi
Student Representative, MBA 2016-18, DMS IIT Delhi
Admissions Coordinator 2017, DMS IIT Delhi
@AdCom_DMS_IITD Does the interview process take place at IIT Delhi only? No other metros or telephonic interview?
CAT 99.01, 10th 86, 12th 84, BE 70, work ex 19 months ? No call. Cutoff details please!
What is the current strength of students under DMS and DLT programs?
Anyone with interview on April 8th morning slot, travelling from chennai?
Will there be a second list by DLT?
After reading all the posts right since the time of application, IIT D DOMS is the only b-school in the creamy layer which is still outdated to the core... send applications by post, pay 3200 for it (even the top most don't charge so much), get an acknowledgement without even a serial number or application number, results will be on a pdf.. duh! you can't expect it to be on a db!, top of all unfair shortlisting and no "clear" reply to any of the mails!
I haven't seen more chaos and unfairness in any of the top b-schools! I went on to mail to the adcom, but after so many people's efforts going in vain, I thought I wasted my time too! And above all, honestly I didn't expect this from a top "B-school".. asking myself what a well-organized and fair "B-school" and why did I waste so much of my time and money
Overall: 85.75 VA: 67.36 DI: 94.97 QA: 82.89 NC-OBC, Female. X: 85.6% XII: 78.25% BE: 69.3%, running an NGO for 3 years, online marketing analyst at a product co., for 1.5 years, freelance writer, leadership roles, awards. What would be my composite score? There's no way to find the formula! @AdCom_DMS_IITD
What is lowest Composite Score that got shortlisted??
Mine is 81.3. GSM ( general-Science-Male)
Anyone with less than this composite score got shortlisted??
ty :)
Response recieved from DOMS IITD for the clarification, pasting below-
" In your category and programme, the SI cut off is 78.5. However, in your case the SI is 77.38. This is the reason you are not shortlisted. The detailed calculation of SI is provided below:
CAT % = 98.13x60/100 = 58.878
Graduation = 8.11 GCPA = (8.11-0.75)*10= 73.60% = 4.5
10+2= 90.2 = 7
10= 91.4 = 4
Addition Qualification = 0
Experience 20 Months = 3
Total SI = 77.378(77.38)
However, the SI calculated by you is simply multiplying respective % with the weights. DMS, IIT Delhi apply weightage distribution for each component like graduation, 10+2, 10, Work ex., Additional Qualification. For example your graduation marks is 8.11, therefore, as per approved weight distribution 4.5 has been given for graduation, Similarly, Calculations are done for other components.
with regardsDMS, IIT Delhi"
Not able to understand 4.5 / 15 for graduation for 8.11 CGPA
is it a good way of accessing?
Just my view, "Lets not compare aspirants only based on CAT scores, just those who all have, say 90+ percentile, should have equal opportunity to fight and get a seat". May be different way of selection, non-indian style, score-lite shortlist...
A guy who has done class 10 from CBSE can never get 5/5. This is absolutely insane. 😂😂😂
Must say , what a dumb shortlisting criteria !!!!
@AdCom_DMS_IITD - If I have a proof of CGPA to percentage conversion from the college, won't it work? or the criteria decided by DMS would be the final one?
@AdCom_DMS_IITD Based on the method provided by IIT Delhi to convert CGPA into percentage, I am getting 80.9%.But I have secured 83.81 % in my B.Tech. Detail-Cat-96.26 percentile ,Calss 12-78.6% Class 10th-96.8% and Work Ex-15 months.
Can you tell me the reason for my disqualification???